""
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:53 AM.  

Go Back   WiiNewz Forums > Nintendo Wii Forums > Reviewz
Recommended Shops

 
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1 (permalink)  
Old 03-02-2007, 09:20 PM
xiaNaix's Avatar
Administrator
 
Join Date: Jan 2002
Posts: 1,745
Wiikey Review

The Wiikey is advertised as "the first and only upgradeable modchip" for the Wii. It's list of features is quite impressive...
Code:

    * Direct boot of wii backups
    * Direct boot of GC backups
    * Direct boot of homebrew in GC mode
    * Supports all currently available console/drive versions
    * Supports D2B chipsets
    * Sophisticated (true) update mechanism via DVD (future proof, expect cool features to come)
    * Direct boot of different NTSC region Wii games/backups on US and JAP consoles
    * Partial support for NTSC region Wii games/backups on PAL consoles
    * Boots different region GC games/backups (partially without swapping)
    * Supports multi-disc games for BOTH Wii and Gamecube
    * Supports DVD-R / true DVD+R and +RW support (no bitsetting required!)
    * Improved readsettings for recordable media
    * Built-in audio fix
    * Supports fullsize 4GB discs for gamecube homebrew
    * Stealth mode
    * 512 byte EEPROM to store configuration
    * Quicksolder interface - no wires required
    * Unique disc backup application via sdcard
    * Compact design, best quality components, rock solid high speed controller
    * Professional ESD packing
    * Recovery mode - Can recover from a bad flash
But will it live up to the hype?

Packaging
The Wiikey is shipped in a small ESD bag. The actual chip is very small... about half the size of the CycloWiz. The board is also a bit thicker than the CycloWiz. The picture below shows the Wiikey compared to a standard CD case, a U.S. nickel, and an English Pound.


Photo provided by thieves like us

Installation
We installed the Wiikey in a U.S. version Wii with the DMS chipset to replace a previous wired CycloWiz install. We chose to use wires but the chip also provides "quicksolder" points for those who wish to use them. There are six points to solder, as opposed to five for the Wiinja and CycloWiz. The new point is no more difficult than any of the others, though, so it should not be a problem.

We found that the "quicksolder" points did not align perfectly so some adjusting may be required to get everything lined up. The pads are bigger than those of the CycloWiz, though, to provide an easier wired install. That is the option we chose to use.


Photo provided by thieves like us

Setup
The Wiikey comes configured to play Wii and GameCube backups standard from the factory. If you wish to play imports, you must download the Setup Disc from the official website. Be sure to get the proper version that matches the origin of your Wii console. The disc runs in GameCube mode so, if you have a GC controller, be sure to have it plugged in when running the Setup Disc. If you do not have a GameCube controller, the Wiikey Team was courteous enough to also provide versions that allow the options to be changed by pressing the RESET button on the Wii console. This is an ingenious solution for those who may be stuck without a GameCube controller.

The Setup Disc includes options for the Region Free setting (OFF/ON), GameCube Audio Fix (ON/OFF), and Disc Speed. Early Wii modchips, such as the Wiinja and CycloWiz, were plagued with Disc Read Errors on some games. It was later reported, by Brakken of TehSkeen in his CycloWiz review, that the problem was with the chips not allowing the disc to spin at 6x like they should. This caused problems with several major titles. It is best advised to leave this setting at 6x unless there is reason to change it later.

Once you have selected your settings, simply choose "Save Settings" and there will be a delay of about 10 seconds while they are written to the Wiikey's onboard EEPROM. You will not need to run the Setup Disc again unless you want to change a setting.


Photos provided by thieves like us


Performance
The Wiikey performed simply flawlessly with everything we threw at it, including games burned on re-writeable media! The games tested included previous problem titles such as "WarioWare," "Rayman: Raving Rabbids," and "Call Of Duty." Opening movies played seamlessly even when left to loop for 30+ minutes. Each game played perfectly with no DRE's whatsoever. We got caught up playing "WarioWare" for 2-3 hours and didn't experience a single Disc Read Error.

We also tested a wide variety of unpatched Japanese games. All performed exactly as if they were running on a Japanese console with no errors of any kind. Titles included "Wing Island," Kororinpa,"Cooking Mama," "Fire Emblem," "Pokemon Battle Stadium," and "Ennichi No Tatsujin," which can be seen in the video linked at the end of this section.

We were also able to boot several PAL titles without patching. "Super Fruit Fall" and the U.K. version of "Rayman: Raving Rabbids," which includes 480p support dropped in the NTSC version, loaded and played flawlessly. Your display needs to support PAL mode, though. We were testing on Sony and Westinghouse LCD sets.

The GameCube support was also spot-on. We were able to boot GameCube imports (Jap & PAL) without using GCOS. Again, though, if you are going to run a PAL game on your NTSC Wii (or vice versa) your display will need to support it. If it doesn't, simply use GCOS to boot and force the video mode to whatever you need. We asume this is what they meant when listing "partially without swapping" in the specs.

Unfortunately, the advertised "Audiofix" feature simply does not work. Any games requiring this functionality will run with garbled audio. Wiikey has promised a fix but, three months later, it still has not been released. Other chips have a working fix but some do not fully correct the problem. At this time, the only mod with a fully working Audiofix is the Wiinja Deluxe.


Homebrew Support
We did not get a chance to fully test GameCube hombrew (emulators, etc.) yet. Considering the flawless execution of GameCube backups, though, I do not forsee any problems with running various homebrew apps.

Postitive Points
Easy to install, whether "quicksolder" or wired, if you have soldering experience.
Performed flawlessly, even on same discs that gave DRE's with the previously installed CycloWiz.
Plays games burned onto Re-Writeable Discs!
Does not require GCOS to play GameCube imports (see above for video mode info).
Truly upgradeable with onboard EEPROM.

Negative Points
The thickness of the board and position of the quicksolder points (which don't line up quite perfectly) may require a bit more skill to install than you'd expect.
Update promised three months ago still not released. Worst support of any modchip on the market.

Overall For Wii titles, the Wiikey is performs as well as any other modchip on the market right now. We did not experience a single issue during our lengthy testing. We were so impressed with it's quality that a friend decided to take the plunge and add one to his D2B console. It also performed 100% as advertised without a hiccup. Unfortunately, the lack of proper GameCube audiofix and horrible support from the team has forced us to lower the review score. Until they deliver on their promises, Wiinja Deluxe is the king of the mountain.


Final Verdict
05 out of 10
Wiikey promised an update to correct the GameCube audio issue months ago. Release dates were announced then came and went. As a result, we have lowered our original 09/10 score by a point each week. If you are looking for a fully featured modchip with top-notch support we recommend the Wiinja Deluxe.

Official Site: http://www.wiikey.cn
 

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On
Forum Jump



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:53 AM.